If you’re like most Americans, you might dread the annual performance review. What’s more, what if your boss criticizes you?
It’s a stressful and dramatic experience full of employee performance review mistakes. When you’re the one conducting the review, it isn’t much better. It can be uncomfortable to explain to an employee if their performance is lacking, or even more uncomfortable if you’re in a position to lay off employees.
But there’s no need to fret because we’ve put together a handy checklist so you don’t commit these employee performance review mistakes. Keep reading to learn more.
Don’t Wait Until It’s Too Late to Give Feedback
Giving feedback is a critical part of a manager’s job, yet it’s often one of the most difficult things to do. Employees need feedback to know how they’re doing and what they can improve on.
The employee will also be less likely to trust the feedback if they feel like they haven’t been getting it throughout the year. To avoid this mistake, give feedback regularly. Let employees know what they’re doing well and what they need to work on. This will help them improve their performance and build trust.
Avoid Making Assumptions About an Employee’s Performance
In creating performance reviews it is important to avoid making assumptions about an employee’s performance. This can be based on several factors, such as how long the employee has been with the company, their position within the company, or even their personal relationship with the reviewer.
These assumptions can lead to reviewers making inaccurate and unfair judgments in reviewing employee performance. To avoid making this mistake, it is important to gather accurate information about an employee’s performance before the review.
This can be done through regular check-ins, observing their work, and/or asking for feedback from their direct reports. By taking the time to get to know an employee’s actual performance, you can avoid making assumptions that could impact the fairness of their review.
Make Sure Your Employee Performance Review Mistakes Are Objective and Specific
Common mistakes include making the review process too personal, not being specific enough, and not providing objective feedback. Remember that your review should have concrete, objective information, keeping your personal opinions separate.
To avoid making these mistakes, it is important to keep the review process as professional and objective as possible. Try to avoid any personal comments, and be as specific as possible when describing both positive and negative aspects of an employee’s performance.
To make sure that your review is satisfactory, you need to have employee performance review software. It is a useful tool that offers a variety of benefits. Learn about how it works here in this analysis, just keep on reading for more info.
Don’t Be Afraid to Give Constructive Criticism
Don’t avoid giving constructive criticism out of fear of upsetting the employee. This leads to employees not receiving feedback that could help them improve their work.
Another mistake is giving criticism that is vague and unspecific. Instead of saying, “Your work needs improvement,” say, “Your organizational skills need improvement,” followed up by specific examples and ways they can improve their work.
To avoid these mistakes, managers should be clear and specific when giving criticism, focus on both positive and negative aspects of performance, and make an effort to avoid upsetting the employee.
Always End on a Positive Note
Another mistake you can make during an employee performance review is to always end on a positive note. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t let your employee know you appreciate the work they’re doing, but ensure you do so in a genuine way without sounding condescending.
If your employee needs to step up their game, don’t gloss over it as you end the conversation. Let them know you’ll be revisiting any issues periodically.
Give specifics of what they need to work on, along with their strengths and weaknesses. Try to end the conversation by scheduling a time to reconvene and discuss how their performance has advanced.
Setting Expectations for Performance Reviews
If an employer comes in with a negative or confrontational attitude, it will only make the employee defensive and less likely to be receptive to constructive feedback. Instead, try to come in with a positive attitude and an open mind.
Another common mistake is failing to give specific, concrete examples of both good and bad performance. This can leave employees feeling frustrated and confused about what is expected of them. Be sure to give specific examples of both what is working well and what could be improved.
If your employee does an exemplary job with completing assignments but lacks the ability to turn them in on time, let them know. Explain to them that you value their quality of work, but that they need to improve time management.
Avoid the temptation to use the performance review as a chance to vent about all of the employees’ shortcomings. This will only serve to further damage the relationship and make your employee even less receptive to feedback. Stick to the facts and focus on giving constructive criticism that will help the employee grow and improve.
Giving Feedback During Performance Reviews
Don’t focus on the negative and ignore the positive. This can make your employee feel like they’re being attacked, which can make them act defensive and less likely to listen to your feedback. Another mistake is to be vague or convoluted in your language.
Be clear and concise in your feedback so the employee can understand what they need to work on. Finally, avoid making personal comments or remarks that could be construed as offensive. If you keep these things in mind, you can avoid common performance review mistakes and give feedback that is helpful and productive.
Consequences of Employee
Performance reviews can be tricky, but there are ways to prepare and make sure you’re putting your best foot forward. Avoid these employee performance review mistakes and you’ll be on your way to a successful review.
If you enjoyed this article, then make sure that you explore our blog. For more, read interesting articles click here!